A persistent problem with the Patreon for Wordpress plugin: every time I’ve used it to put images behind a “for logged-in patrons only” paywall, and then activated any kind of caching plugin, the caching plugin just serves a cached version of the paywalled images to everyone.
Here’s an example post with paywalled images on the BICP website, where the Siteground Speed Optimizer plugin is happily ignoring the Patreon lock. For comparison, here’s how the locking is supposed to work, when there’s no other plugin interfering:
Keyboard cat should only be visible to $1-and-up patrons:

Food coma cat should only be visible to $5-and-up patrons:

Coat rack cat should only be visible to $10-and-up patrons:

So I went to Siteground’s tech-support section.
These days, the first thing it shoves on you is an “Instant AI Assistant.” There’s no disclaimer, no “this feature is experimental and may give wrong information” warning, just the advertising fluff of “We have integrated ChatGPT by OpenAI and heavily trained the model to resolve specific issues for clients hosted on SiteGround platform” and “Explore the power of AI and get instant, expert assistance.”
My opening line:
“Your caching plugin doesn’t work with images that are paywalled by the Patreon plugin.”
The LLM offered three troubleshooting steps: exclude the image URLs from caching (I already did), make sure the plugins are up-to-date (I already did), and:
“Disable Image Optimization for Specific Plugins: If the issue persists, you might need to disable image optimization for the Patreon plugin. This can be done by adjusting the settings in the Speed Optimizer plugin.”
I replied that I did the first two (all on the BICP website, I don’t even have the plugin active here on the Leif & Thorn site — not that the LLM asked), and:
“I don’t see an option to disable image optimization for the Patreon plugin specifically.”
The LLM offered three new troubleshooting steps: exclude the page URLs from caching (I already did), check for other unspecified “conflicting settings” (I already did), and clear the existing cache after any setting changes (I already…you get the picture).
I replied that I did, and added:
“Was “you might need to disable image optimization for the Patreon plugin. This can be done by adjusting the settings in the Speed Optimizer plugin” just completely hallucinated?”
The LLM opened its next response with:
“I apologize for any confusion. The Speed Optimizer plugin does not have a specific setting to disable image optimization for individual plugins like Patreon.”
(And then it suggested I make sure the site can execute cron jobs successfully. For less-techy readers: whenever a pre-scheduled comic gets published on time, which the BICP site does almost every day, that’s because of a cron job getting executed successfully.)
So, hey — great service here, SiteGround. I really hope OpenAI is the one paying you to pad out their list of “companies that are totally using ChatGPT”, because if you’re giving money to OpenAI just to get a robot that lies to your customers, that’s a terrible investment.
It’s been a good, solid hosting platform otherwise! All I need is for them to stop wasting their time with LLMs, and focus on basic, functional updates. You know, like “fixing their caching plugin.”
—
A nice update: I had a chat with a human customer-service rep! They talked me through some Actual Troubleshooting, then escalated the case to a higher level of tech support!
It took about 40 minutes of back-and-forth — but this was the good kind. Where the rep only asked about steps I hadn’t already tried, used the results to make meaningful decisions about what to try next, and never suggested “what if you change this nonexistent plugin setting I just made up.”
Update 2: Opening response from next-level tech support was, they figured out “if you turn off the caching features, the paywalled content works.”
Yeah. we already know that. The problem is, because of some persistent overall issues with site performance, I want the caching features on.
Update 3: After some bonus testing, it seems like the Speed Optimizer plugin can be on, and not interfere with Patreon image-locking, as long as this under-the-hood setting for NGINX Direct Delivery is off:

Which means, here’s my new wishlist: either (a) an update to this feature so it respects .htaccess rules (those are how the Patreon plugin manages the image-locking), or (b) an alternative that can be configured to respect .htaccess rules.
Doesn’t seem likely I’ll get either of those any time soon. Sigh.
Meanwhile, I’m pretty sure tech support turned on the SO plugin here, and caused some surprise new problems. (I was specifically using the BICP site for testing, to avoid surprise problems on the Leif & Thorn site.) Hopefully those are fixed now. Fingers crossed.
Comment Header
2 Comments
*giant eyeroll*
somehow not surprised at all…
Damn that is infuriating.
(Every time my eye processed ‘caching’ I heard ‘ka-CHING!’ as in OpenAI’s coffers graciously opening wide for more ill-gotten gains).
Comment Footer